Will You Be My Maid of Honor? Fun Proposal Ideas and Gifts

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, meaning we earn commissions if you shop through the links below. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclaimer for more info.

So, you’ve said “yes” to the love of your life, and now it’s time to pop the next big question: “Will you be my Maid of Honor?” However, in today’s wedding world, a simple question doesn’t seem to be the norm anymore! Brides are stepping up their game, turning the Maid of Honor proposal into a memorable experience.

Choosing your Maid of Honor is a significant decision. Your MOH has a checklist of responsibilities, and as such, should be dependable, organized, and above all, someone who understands and supports your vision for your big day. She’ll accompany you on epic wedding dress shopping adventures, planning unforgettable bachelorette parties, and orchestrating an incredible bridal shower.

So it’s understandable that you want to make her (or him!) feel special when asking to head up your bride squad. While simply asking your bestie straight out is completely acceptable, this article will explore how you can add creativity and fun when popping the all-important question to your chosen MOH-to-be.

Ready to dive into some creative MOH proposal ideas and thoughtful gifts? Let’s get started!

How do you ask someone to be your Maid of Honor?

Okay, on to the big question: how do you ask someone to be your Maid of Honor? The truth is you don’t have to go big; in fact, some of the most memorable Maid of Honor proposals come from small, personal gestures that represent your relationship.

Here are three quick, low-expense, and low-effort ideas that will still leave your future Maid of Honor feeling over the moon special:

  • Handwritten Note: Take a moment to craft a heartfelt letter expressing why she means so much to you and why you want her by your side. This personal touch can be incredibly touching.
  • Favorite Treats: Gift her with a small box of her favorite sweets or snacks. It’s a simple gesture that shows you know and appreciate her tastes.
  • Memory Booklet: Create a mini scrapbook or photo album filled with your shared memories. Include funny anecdotes, cherished photos, and inside jokes to evoke nostalgia and celebrate your friendship.

These small but thoughtful gestures can make a big impact, making your Maid of Honor feel important and excited to join you on this journey. That said, some brides like to “go big or go home” with their Maid of Honor proposals. But how do you do just that?

To give us some big ideas, we consulted with Megan Nova, a wedding planner and author from AwesomeBridal

According to Megan, “creativity is key when it comes to popping the Maid of Honor proposal.” 

Here are three unique ideas to consider:

1. Cinema Proposal

Imagine this: you and your potential Maid of Honor settle in for a cozy movie night at the local cinema. Little does she know, you’ve arranged a surprise for her. As the credits roll, a slideshow featuring precious moments from your friendship appears on the big screen. 

The last slide or a final segment of a video reveals your heartfelt proposal. It’s a cinematic twist on the traditional question and will surely leave her speechless. Yes, this idea might take some work and a partnership with your local theater, but trust us, it can be done!

Megan says, “The cinema proposal adds an element of surprise and grandeur to the moment. It’s like your friendship unfolding on the silver screen.”

2. Handwritten Letters

In today’s digital world, handwritten letters remain timeless treasures. Many brides take this approach because it’s personal, heartfelt, and cost-effective. Pen down your thoughts, recount your special memories, and express why you want her to be your Maid of Honor. Your handwritten letter will become a cherished keepsake, a tangible reminder of your bond.

And if you love this approach but are not word-savvy, reach out to a freelance copywriter for help. Copywriters love the opportunity to work with brides to create a heartfelt letter to help you ask the big question. They’ll likely be willing to help you with your vows, too, if you need assistance!

Megan emphasizes, “Handwritten letters are simple, but they carry a deep emotional connection. Your Maid of Honor will likely keep it close, symbolizing your enduring friendship.”

3. Hiking Trail Proposal

For the adventurous bride, a hiking trail can be the perfect setting for a memorable proposal. Invite your potential Maid of Honor on a scenic hike and strategically place cues along the trail that evoke fond memories of your friendship. 

When you reach the peak, present her with a “Will you be my Maid of Honor?” card. Don’t forget to pack snacks and a camera to capture the moment. Better yet, have another friend (hint, hint: your groom or spouse-to-be) there hiding out with a camera in hand.

Megan adds, “The hiking trail proposal combines adventure and sentimentality. It’s a fantastic way to create a lasting memory together.”

These creative Maid of Honor proposals offer a personal touch and make the “Will you be my Maid of Honor?” moment unforgettable. Choose the one that resonates most with your friendship or use these ideas to help you come up with one of your own.

4. Wellness Retreat Experience 

Consider that many ladies today appreciate experiences over gifts. And what could be a more perfect experience than treating your future Maid of Honor to a luxurious wellness retreat? Spoil your bestie for a day before asking her to step into this important role.

Megan says, “Choose a top-rated location that offers an array of indulgent services, from saunas and steam baths to massages, body scrubs, and waxing.” It’s the ultimate way to celebrate her saying YES!

Will you Be My Maid of Honor? Proposal Gift Ideas

As Megan wisely puts it, “Maid of honor proposal gifts aren’t a must, though recently, they have been normalized. However, brides shouldn’t feel obligated to give gifts.” 

This said, if you are open to the idea of giving gifts, here are some of the best MOH proposal gift ideas. While not obligatory, these thoughtful tokens of appreciation can add an extra layer of joy to the moment. 

So, if you’re considering a gift to sweeten the deal, here are some fantastic ideas to consider.

Edible MOH Proposal Gifts

Indulge her sweet tooth with a delectable assortment of chocolates, custom cookies, or even moon cakes.

MOH proposal cookies

MOH Proposal Box of Cookies

Customized cookies are a fun (and tasty!) option, allowing you to pop the question with the question itself. You can even include a picture of you and your bestie, adding a nostalgic twist to your proposal.

Be My Maid of Honor Chocolates

Is your MOH-to-be a chocoholic? Then this is the perfect way to her heart. 18 decadent chocolate squares, (available in milk, dark or white) will spell out the important question, and this unique gift will be presented in an attractive white gift box with satin bow.

MOH chocolates
MOH proposal macarons

MOH Proposal Macarons

These delectable macarons offer a unique way to ask, “Will you be my Maid of Honor?” With 5 beautifully prepared handmade treats, who would be able to resist?

Unique MOH Proposal Gifts

MOH Scratch-Off Cards

Create a sense of anticipation by presenting her with a custom scratch-off card. Just like that thrill of scratching off the winning lottery number, your prospective Maid of Honor will experience the same excitement when she unveils the hidden message that asks her to be your Maid of Honor.

It’s a unique way to pop the big question, adding an extra layer of fun and surprise to your proposal that she’s sure to love.

Be my MOH scratch off card
MOH Proposal Puzzle Card

MOH Proposal Puzzle Card

Turn the proposal into an engaging game with a customized puzzle. Use one of your favorite photos together, a snapshot of a special memory that only the two of you share. Then, as she diligently assembles it, piece by piece, she’ll uncover the hidden message, adding an element of intrigue and anticipation to the proposal. 

MODERN MOH TIP: Have another puzzle made for her after the wedding, featuring a moment of you two on the big day!

Smells like a Maid of Honor Candle

We love candles as gifts here at Modern MOH, and it’s no different with the MOH proposal gift. Selecting a style or scent you know she loves can add a personal touch. If you’re looking for a fun recommendation, we adore the “smells like a Maid of Honor” candle. 

If you prefer to use a candle you already have, you can simply order the label to add that special touch to your proposal!

Smells like MOH candle

Personalized “Will you Be my Maid of Honor?” Gifts

Silver Wren necklace

Silver Wren Necklace

Jewelry is a timeless gift, and we especially admire the simplicity and charming elegance of The Silver Wren necklace. This handmade item features a lovely quartz gemstone, a spring ring closure, and a cable chain style with adjustable length. 

What makes it extra special is the personal touch—it can be customized with her initial or a significant date, adding sentimental value to this beautiful keepsake. Plus, it comes packaged in a box that reads, “I couldn’t say ‘I do’ without you,” making it a thoughtful and stylish way to ask, “Will you be my Maid of Honor?”

Customized Wine Labels

Raise a toast to your future together with a bottle of her favorite wine or champagne. Attach a fun label with your Maid of Honor proposal message to make it extra special.

Pairs Well MOH Wine Label
Friends MOH Glass

Friends MOH Wine Glass

If your Maid of Honor enjoys a good drink, personalized wine glasses are a fun and practical gift choice. You can add a playful twist by engraving them with your proposal question or a special message. We have a soft spot for this Friends-inspired glass that reads, “The one where you’re my maid of honor.” 

It’s a witty way to pop the question, and you can even order it with or without her name (or his name for your Man of Honor). The choice is entirely up to you, adding an extra layer of personalization to your proposal.

MOH Proposal Boxes

A proposal box is like a miniature treasure chest filled with goodies. There are many options available if you want something ready-made – just pick the mix that best reflects your bestie.

Maid of Honor Proposal Box

We particularly adore this Maid Of Honor Gift Set. It includes a personalized “Will You Be My Maid Of Honor” card, a mini dried floral bundle, a rose petal roll-on fragrance oil, a floral soy candle (4oz), floral bath salts, and a rose quartz heart. 

This thoughtful collection creates a package that not only sets the mood for your proposal but also adds an extra layer of sentimental charm. It’s a gesture that will surely make your Maid of Honor feel cherished and excited to join you on your wedding journey.

Maid Of Honor Proposal Gift Box
MOH box with tumbler

Proposal Box with Tumbler

If you’re looking for a box that has it all, then look no further! With the luxe box, you will be able to create a custom box including items such as a compact mirror, lip balm, hair scrunchies, sunglasses, tumbler, luggage tag, wine stopper, can cooler, candle, and bath bomb!

Your maid of honor will feel like she’s won the jackpot! While we know that you’re actually the lucky one to have such a good friend stand by your side on one of the biggest days of your life!

Maid of Honor Spa Gift Set

Help your maid of honor-to-be relax in advance of the wedding craziness with this thoughtful self-care proposal box.

Including items such as scented candles, organic loose-leaf teas, natural honey, and other indulgent treats, this is the perfect gift to help her take care of herself so she can help take care of you! Make your gift personalized with a custom personal message printed on a card.

MOH spa proposal box

Wrapping Up your Maid of Honor Proposal

You’ve picked out the perfect gift, now don’t forget that the wrapping and packaging can add an extra layer of excitement and fun. We’ve curated a list of some of our favorite ways for you to complete the package.


A heartfelt card is the classic choice, but it’s all about the personal touch. Write a message that reflects your unique bond with your Maid of Honor or Matron of Honor to be, and choose a card design that resonates with both of you.

Gift Bags

A customized gift bag not only presents your proposal in style but can also give her a practical keepsake she can use long after the big day. Consider adding her name or a fun phrase that embodies your friendship.

Customized Gift Boxes

Not keen on the pre-made proposal boxes and want to make your own? No worries, you can have a gorgeous customized gift box made and fill it with all your own special goodies.

With these creative packaging ideas, you’ll make the final moments of your Maid of Honor proposal as memorable as the entire experience.

What to Look for in a Maid of Honor Proposal Gift?

When choosing a Maid of Honor proposal gift, consider something that reflects your unique bond, their personality, and showcases your appreciation. It should evoke emotions, make her feel special, and serve as a reminder of this significant moment. 

Whether it’s a heartfelt letter, personalized jewelry, or a thoughtful experience, look for a gift that speaks to your relationship and sets the tone for the exciting journey ahead.

Frequently Asked Questions 

Curious about the ins and outs of Maid of Honor proposal ideas? And what about bridesmaid proposal ideas? We’ve got you covered with answers to the most common questions to help you navigate this exciting part of your wedding journey.

Do I need to give my Maid of Honor a proposal gift?

It’s all about personal preference. While etiquette doesn’t mandate a Maid of Honor proposal gift, it’s a thoughtful gesture to ignite excitement for upcoming events. Plus, considering the financial responsibility your Maid of Honor will embrace, a proposal gift is often a welcomed token of appreciation for her support and commitment.

What if my Maid of Honor doesn’t live close to me?

No worries! Distance can’t dampen the Maid of Honor spirit. Embrace technology with virtual proposals—think Zoom calls or surprise doorstep deliveries. Plan a fun online game or trivia night to pop the question. Your Maid of Honor will feel the love from afar, and you’ll create a memorable proposal, no matter the miles that separate you!

The Bottom Line

In the wedding planning journey, the “Will You Be My Maid of Honor?” moment is a highlight you both will be sure to cherish forever. From creative proposals that reflect your unique bond to thoughtful gifts and packaging that add extra fun, it’s all about celebrating the extraordinary friendships that make your big day even more special. 

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach, so let your personality shine and make the proposal uniquely yours. Here’s to the adventures, laughter, and unforgettable moments with your incredible Maid of Honor! Cheers!

UP NEXT: What is an Honorary Bridesmaid? All Your Questions Answered

Maid of Honor Planner

Packed full of detailed checklists, worksheets, and budget trackers, our exclusive maid of honor planner covers everything you need to know (and more) as a maid of honor!

Pin for Later!

will you be my maid of honor pin
maid of honor proposal pin
maid of honor proposal gifts pin
Will You Be My Maid of Honor? Fun Proposal Ideas and GiftsWill You Be My Maid of Honor? Fun Proposal Ideas and GiftsWill You Be My Maid of Honor? Fun Proposal Ideas and Gifts